| 2022 J. Thomas Peterson, "Deep Ascent" |  |
| 2021 Todd Bird, "Gus" |  |
| 2020 Jeffrey Field, "Icebox" |  |
| 2019 Caitlin Stowe, "Don't Call Me Rebecca" |  |
| 2018 Tom Zanca, "Standoff" |  |
| 2017 Drew Wagner, "Beardless" |  |
| 2016 Jeffrey Palmer, "Split Costs" |  |
| 2015 Jeffrey Field, "Bad Heir Day" |  |
| 2014 Jenni Prange Boran, "Blue Bunny" |  |